 |
|
Facing the medical reality of obesity-related diseases
challenges kids to take responsibility for their current
and future health. |
|
A Grassroots Approach
to
Obesity
and Disease
by Dexter Louie, M.D.
Is there anything community
physicians can do about the epidemic of childhood obesity?
Of course we can treat the resulting diseases, after diagnosing problem.
But simply treating obesity-related diseases will not stop the epidemic.
Over the past year we
have had bans on junk food and sodas on school campuses, regulations
on what kind of foods are served at schools, policies aimed at controlling
food choices, and even attempts to sue fast food companies for being the
cause of obesity. In my opinion, there is another approach, one that is not
legislative or "top-down." It is a grassroots approach that involves
community physicians and students. It is focused on engaging students, the
next generation of potentially obese adults, getting student buy-in, and
transitioning the next generation to healthier food choices and more physical
activity.
We all know the numbers.
Approximately 61 percent of adults and 15 to 20 percent of children are overweight
or obese. In some predominantly black and Hispanic communities, 40
to 50 percent of children are overweight/obese. Unfortunately, the vast majority
of these overweight children will remain so as adults. The
health care cost of obesity is estimated at over $100 billion/year.
Yes, the numbers are huge.
No longer are we a society of hunter-gatherers, burning up all the calories
we consume. We now have the ability to produce and consume
food far in excess of what we need to survive, leaving us with
ever-increasing girths and body mass indices. This problem developed over
time, mostly involving the past 2 to 3 generations. The solution, too, will
take time and involve more than one generation.
This grassroots approach
links volunteer community physicians with school “site champions” to
develop programs specific to their schools and communities.
The site champion can be a school nurse, administrator, teacher, or PTA member--anyone
who is interested in student health and the problem of obesity. The site
champion arranges for a volunteer physician to speak to classes or groups of
students, explaining the health issues of obesity, diabetes, heart disease, and
so on. When I do it, I try to bring the medical reality of obesity and life-long
diseases from the medical office and hospital to the classroom. I don't just
talk about the food pyramid. Students do not like to be lectured to or told what
to do. But when they are challenged to take responsibility for their current
and future health, they can become engaged, there can be buy-in, and there
can be a change in behavior at a peer level.
Top-down is not the strategy
here. A ban is simply a ban if there is no student buy-in. To achieve this
buy-in, students need to be actively involved. This program is student-based,
student-driven.The goal is for students to change behavior and to make better
choices. I believe that if students understand the relationship between junk
food, inactivity, and obesity, diabetes, and other diseases, they will be
effective in:
- managing/reducing junk
food in their schools and in their lives and
- improving
their own health and the health of their peers, their family, and
their community.
Students Take Charge
At one school, Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School, I presented the obesity
problem, and the students did the rest. They brainstormed the health issues,
researched junk food, fast food, healthy foods, and physical activity, and then
developed a plan for their school and their community. They addressed the issues
of revenue, freedom of choice, food services, vendors, pricing, and regulations.
The students conducted taste testing, student body surveys, health awareness
programs, and vendor interviews, and including free vendor samples of healthy
foods. Only 5 to 10 percent of student athletes are at highly competitive levels,
so the students developed noncompetitive physical activity programs.
| |
 |
| |
At Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School, students wait
in line at the "Milk Chug" vending machine. |
|
|
Within one year, the students
made significant changes at their school and in their behavior. For example,
the students initiated removal of one soda machine and had installed a “Milk
Chug” machine
that dispenses low-fat milk, water, and juices. I observed students lined
up 10 to 20 deep at a time to buy milk, versus one student at the soft drink
machine. I saw additional milk purchases during the snack periods between
classes. The milk machine is restocked daily, while the soda machine is restocked
twice a month. Students were happier with the lunch offerings, since they
were involved in selecting what went on the menu. One parent told me that
her 7th grader chastised her for drinking a soda because sodas were simply
sugar and a bunch of empty calories.
“What I find exciting
is that the kids are taking ownership, rather than having it forced on them
by adults, which in my experience never works anyway,” said school principal
Mr. Paul Simonin.
What does it take for
a community physician to get involved in this type of grassroots program,
and an otolaryngologist at that? After 2 years on this project, I found that
it took commitment, patience, tenacity, and about 10 hours per year working
with the students and the school site champion. Changes in schools take time,
sometimes a very long time. Once the students take on the project, I communicated
with the school site champion, who was my liaison to the students and school
administration. My role was to bring the medical reality of obesity and junk
food and diabetes to the classroom and to challenge the students to make
the necessary changes at their school, in their lives, and in their community.
I made a total of four visits to the school, first to present the obesity
issue, then to hear the students' progress reports on a regular basis. The
students developed a timeline and were responsible for presentations to me.
Over the past year I worked by e-mail with the school site champion and we
acted as consultants, but allowed the students to independently research,
develop, and carry out their program
| |
|
| |
Click
here to view a video produced
by the 2003 Leadership Class of
Joaquin Moraga Intermediate School. |
|
|
This grassroots, student-based, student-driven approach is but one means of trying to stop the epidemic of obesity and to control the increase in obesity-related diseases. This approach is adaptable to varying socioeconomic, cultural, and academic conditions. I believe it can be successful across different student populations and in different communities. It focuses on this generation of students and allows them to take ownership of their health and to be responsible for making better choices in nutrition and activity.
Dr. Louie is a past president of the San Francisco Medical Society, current SFMS delegate to the CMA House, and current president of the Moraga School Board.